Login  

Sacraments

Holy Orders

Call No One Father?

Mt 23:9Jesus: Call no man "father" on earth [1]verse used to challenge Catholic teachingWhile this verse would appear to be definitive against the Catholic practice of calling priests "father," attempts to reconcile conflicting verses (see selected references below) with such a hard and fast prohibition causes problems. Something else is going on. Looking at the context (e.g., Mt 23:2-12), we find Jesus talking about religious leaders. Jesus is decrying their love of earthly honor and recognition. In context we can see Jesus is simply saying that we should not seek after earthly honors for our religious views or to place such men above God in Heaven. One could think of this as a warning from Jesus, an antidote for earthly pride.
Lk 14:26Jesus: "his father..."Here we see Jesus use "father" to describe others favorably.
Lk 16:24Jesus: calls Abraham "father"
Jn 8:56Jesus: "your father Abraham"
AA 7:2Stephen: "our father Abraham"
AA 22:1Paul addresses some as "fathers"The apostles also use "father" as a title of honor for others.
Rm 4:1Abraham, our forefather...
Rm 4:16-17God, Paul: Abraham="father "
Rm 9:10Paul: "our father Isaac"
1 Cr 4:14-15Paul: "I became your father"The apostles even use the term "father" to describe themselves.
Ep 6:1-2honor your father and motherAnd do not forget that the title is found in the 10 Commandments.
Pp 2:22a son (Timothy) with father (Paul)
1 Th 2:11as a father treats his children
1 Tm 1:2my true child (Paul as "father")
1 Tm 5:1treat older men "as a father"
Pm 1:10I've become father of Onesimus
He 12:7-9earthly fathers to discipline us
Ti 1:4Titus, my true beloved child
Ga 4:19Paul: "my little children"
1 Tm 1:18my son (i.e., Paul=father)
2 Tm 2:1my son (i.e., Paul=father)
1 Pt 5:13Peter: "my son Mark"
1 Jn 2:13-14I write to you, fathers...
1 Jn 2:1John: "my little children..."
3 Jn 1:4John: "my little children..."

Celibacy

1 Tm 4:1-3forbidding marriage is evil [1]verse used to challenge Catholic teaching
1 Tm 6:20avoid profanities of false "knowledge"Paul's conclusion makes clear what he is talking about throughout 1 Timothy. In the Greek, the word for "knowledge" is "gnosis." This was the term used for the secret knowledge taught by the Gnostic heresy of that time. They wrongly believed that matter was evil and only spirit was good. They falsely concluded that marriage and eating were evil because they perpetuated our material lives. Paul is giving Timothy instruction on why and how to avoid the Gnostic heresy.
1 Tm 3:2bishop to be married only once [1]verse used to challenge Catholic teaching
Ep 5:21-33marriage is good, holy [1]verse used to challenge Catholic teachingNote: consecrated celibacy does not equal anti-marriage. Foregoing marriage for the love of God is a "good" in part because what is being given up is also "good" in and of itself. There is no sacrifice in foregoing marriage if marriage were deemed an evil (and clearly it is not).
Is 56:3-4prophecy of celibate priesthood
Je 16:1-4no wife & children for Jeremiah
Mt 19:12celibacy for sake of heaven
Mt 19:29Jesus: reward for giving up all
1 Cr 7:7-9Paul was unmarried, celibate
1 Cr 7:32-35celibacy in Lord's service
1 Tm 5:9-12older widows celibacy pledge
2 Tm 2:3-4avoid civilian entanglements

Priesthood

Gn 14:18Melchizedek
Ps 109:4role of Melchizedek
He 7:1-7Melchizedek, King of Peace
1 Cr 12:4-31different roles of followers
Lk 22:19do this in memory of me
Jn 20:21-22As Father sent me, I send you
AA 1:15-26apostolic succession
AA 6:1-6ordination of deacons laid hands
AA 13:3they laid hands on them
AA 14:22-23presbyters ordained
AA 15:6-23church leaders act in concert
AA 20:28you are guardians of the flock
1 Tm 4:11-13instructions for pastors
1 Tm 4:14gift through laying on of hands
1 Tm 6:3-14exhortation to godliness
2 Tm 1:6imposition of hands = God's gift
2 Tm 2:21st 4 generations of successionPaul (1) has taught Timothy (2), a new bishop, who is to commend faithful men (3), who then are to teach others (4).
Ti 1:5appoint presbyters in every townThe word "priest" is just the modern derivative of the Old English "presbyter."
Ja 5:14-15elders administer sacraments

Notes:

[1]: verse used to challenge Catholic teaching